Wednesday, May 10, 2017

Thoughts provoked by the ten- headed legend



RAAVANAN

WHO DECIDES GOOD & BAD ANYWAY?
If the indicators of a good movie are the strong emotions it evokes and the disturbing thoughts it provokes, then Ravaanan is a good movie.

Ragini's character was beautifully portrayed - a woman with a strong character is a rare phenomenon in Tamil movies, at least in the present - and put to use (except in the climax, which shall be discussed later on). She was asking the right questions. But to the wrong person. For this wonderful tactic, the director should be appreciated.

The dichotomies of good vs. bad; right vs. wrong have been circling in my head for the last 12 hours. Whether a person is a criminal or a man of law and order seems to depend ONLY on which side of the line you are on. What happens when you are on the line? Is it possible to be there, in the first place? 28 encounters could just as easily be translated as 28 murders. Who is the criminal then? If someone who harms or kills another person is a criminal, why are men of law and order given that freedom? Who gave them that? The ultimate question: Can it be given? By anyone?

I believe this is one of the few movies of Maniratnam in which the hero dies. If anyone disagrees about who the hero is… a person who kills the man who saved his life; uses his wife as a bait, a cowardly and manipulative tactic I should add, and kills the man who comes in peace doesn't seem to be much of a hero. Does he?

I wonder as to what drives the "good" man (I'm using it as synonymous for the man upholding law and order)? If it is the motive to kill… is he a man of law and order? Just because he wears an uniform? Or is it only because he wears an uniform? Which ideals lead him? Duty as protector? Supremacy of state? A man appointed by State can kill and torture but not a man appointed by his people? Who decides? And what is their motive? Insecurity that their power to control has been/ will be lost? Fear that the state will be overthrown? Or is it really concern for the innocent civilians in its domain? Is the concern for their safety or whether they would also question its authority?
Another related line of query: who constitutes the innocents? Every person living in their territory? Those who seek their protection explicitly? Those who pay homage to their supremacy? Everyone other than the criminals, their families, those who support them and … those suspected of supporting them?
Like Ragini says, life would be much easier if you can see "bad" people as only bad. To be able to see the world in black and white; when everything, in reality, is shades of grey.

All is fair in love and war. No. I don't think so. The good man goes by this uncivilized principle. While the criminal lets him go, despite having justifiable (again, by whom?) reasons to kill him, because he knows that his motives are tainted by his desire/ love. A weak and illogical strategic move but a true humane decision. And the good man uses that to trap him. Ingenuity? Maybe. Injustice? Definitely. Of course, it was very brave of the good man to come with a huge task force to kill one criminal.

The thoughts that finer emotions weakens your defenses; makes you forget your ideals and your anger; that being human during war is detrimental (is it healthy at other times? Tamil movies protray it as a humongous criminal activity - good people who fight for a cause always die e.g. Madhavan in Evano Oruvan while dons and other random murderers continue living scot-free. Just like in this movie.) are bitter to swallow.

Two questions that I would have liked the movie to answer:
  1. Regarding the forest guard: How did he react to the killing of the younger brother who he led to the camp with promises of peace? Did he expect this to happen? Was he working for the State? Or attempting to solve the problem between the two factions peacefully? Does the fact that he was still in the camp after the murder indicate his loyalty to his duty or his desire to be alive by being on the winning side, regardless of whether it is right or wrong? Is everything allowed in order to save your life, including leading another to death and surviving on the mercy of the person you seek to murder? If your life is so precious, why not his?
  2. The relationship between Ragini and Dev after the encounter/murder. The movie ended at the wrong point: using the woman as a bait and killing the third person in a love triangle is a cliché in Tamil movies. How did this brave woman with strong values and opinions react? Why was it that only mundane grief was expressed? Where were her feelings of rage, love, disgust, confusion; her sense of being betrayed, humiliated and used by the man she regards as god? What was good and bad according to her now? How did she feel about not knowing her husband's real self in however-long-they-were-married but being able to predict the criminal's mind in 14 days? How will she live with her god after this? Will he still be god? The great protector of good and destroyer of evil? Or will he be seen as a paid killer sanctioned by society?

    The final question- who is less dangerous: a man who knows he is a devil and kills or a man who kills in the name of justice and goodness? If truth is relative, then who decides good and bad? And how?
    A totally irrelevant aside: didn't the choice of the name Hemanth for a middle aged person from Thoothukudi strike you as funny?